Stewart's Index or Tillet Porter family main INDEX

Is Susan Porter's information inconsistent with Dew's information?

The following information is from Dew, who claims to be the gtgt granddaughter of the James Tillet Porter born November 21, 1842 and who died July 10, 1933 in Winn Parish, Louisiana. Dew's Porter information may still be at: http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Hills/4693/porter.html

Elisha Porter's ( 1775 - 1840 ) and Miss Stark's ( Abt. 1775 - ? ) son
William Edward Porter ( ? - Aft. 1870 ) and Lucy Bevill ( 1819 - Aft. 1870 )
were the parents of

1. James Tillet Porter ( 1842 - 1933 ) who married Mary Francis Teddlie ( 1847 - 1921 )
   and fathered Jeff Porter and James Albert Porter ( 1871 - 1951 ).

The following information is from the Fri, 19 Jun 1998 email of Sue Porter to Hershel Porter:

Elisha "Lishe" Porter's ( 1773 - 1840 ) and Stark's ( Abt. 1775 - ?) son
John B. Porter ( Abt. 1819 - Bef. 1850 ) and Susan Bevill ( 1819 - Aft. 1870 )
were the parents of

1. Elizabeth Porter ( Abt. 1840 - ? ) and
   
2. James Tillet Porter ( 1842 - ? ).